The X Factor - live show 4 - Rock

1. Joe for Cheryl.
"Don't Stop Believing"
The best voice didn't quite kill it tonight, but it was a case of chalk and cheese, so the boy did well.

2. Lucie for Dannii.
"Sweet Child O' Mine"
The other great voice was a bit off this week, but she gave it her all and the judges were happy.

3. Danyl for Simon.
"Don't Wanna Miss A Thing"
The first verse of this was excruciating, he forgot the lyrics several times... I don't know what Simon's hearing- Dannii was spot on. However, that said, there is something about him I Iike- he doesn't deserve such public hatred.

4. Lloyd for Cheryl.
"I Kissed A Girl"
He can't sing a note, bless him. Dreadful. He doesn't deserve such public support, even if he is Welsh.

5. Stacey for Dannii.
"Somewhere Only We Know"
Nice arrangement. Vocals patchy as always, but some great bits.

6. Jamie for Simon.
"Rocks"
Still don't get what this guy's doing here. More sub-par copycat karaoke, but because it's Simon's act it's fine. But it's not. Far from the worst tonight, however, and easily his best performance to date.

7. Rachel for Dannii.
"One"
Surprisingly good. A few patchy bits, but her best performance so far.

8. Jon & Edward for Louis.
"We Will Rock You"
No you won't. By any definition.

9. Olly for Simon.
"Come Together"
Hate this song, but good performance.

My choice for bottom two - Lloyd and Danyl. Yes, both worse than the twins this week. Just.

-- Posted from my iPhone